At the end when jonas went to cross the boundary of memory, found a sled and after crossing the boundary saw a house exactly same as the memory. Requested the ending of the giver isnt a hallucination. Jonas is fleeing his home with his baby brother gabriel in an effort to end sameness. In the movie the giver, giver jeff bridges showed jonas a sled as past memory.
You could nitpick all the differences, but the bottom line is that this movie was very. In the ending of the gift, gordo reveals his final gift to simon and robyn. Aug 18, 2014 the movie adaptation of the giver, lois lowrys newbery medalwinning ya novel, was years in the making. Yes, thats right, the ending of the giver isnt a hallucination. The arc of the fountain isnt about a man who found the fountain of youth or the tree of life, ate its bark, and lived to be over 500 years old so that he could rejuvenate the tree in a dying. Brings up alot of serious topics for kids and adults like death and memories and love.
She warns him to not repeat the mistake with the last receiver, who is implied to have killed herself. There are many spoilers in the giver book to movie comparison. Lois lowrys homepage here youll find blogs, info about her other books, and snippy answers to faqs. Because of this, he meets a mentoring elder receiver later called the giver. Oct 04, 2002 i read this book back in the fifth grade, well many argue over the ending of it. He longs to be with his daughter, rosemary, the earlier receiverintraining who chose release over living a lonely and isolated life like the giver. While lowry has been blunt about the need for some changesshe told hypable, a. They look at memories of the past world, of joy, of pain, and of love.
This movie is surreal, james garner claims in his biography that it was the worst movie of his career. The giver is a rather straightforward narrative, so you wont get bogged down in ornate language or faulknerlike, pagelong sentences. He pulled on the rope and the sled slowly came to a stop, right next to the girl. Its fairly obvious that the book is infinitely better than its film adaptation, but it was, i think, worth watching. The giver is a 2014 american social science fiction film directed by phillip noyce and starring jeff bridges, brenton thwaites, odeya rush, meryl streep, alexander skarsgard, katie holmes, cameron monaghan, taylor swift, and emma tremblay. Because lowry has written an ambiguous ending to the novel, we dont know what happens to. The movie moves too quickly, speeding through explanations and experiences where the book lingers. In the ending, jonas rides the sled and finds a winter village resembling events in the sleddingmemory he was given. Sure, the sequels can change it, and try to tell you that one set thing happened, but by leaving the ending of the giver separate from the sequels open for analysis makes the meaning so much deeper. I like to leave it that way so that each reader can use his or her imagination and decide what is happening.
In this lesson, discuss these two elements and their meanings in lois lowrys young adult classic, the. Ambiguous means that it can have different explanations. At the end of the giver, jonas and gabe head down through the snow to a place where there is music. In a well organized essay of at least 600 words, explain the ending of the giver as you understand it. Positive although parts of the movie can get a little intense, the giver presents and deals with its tough themes really well. There are two main theories that people like to use before reading the sequels. Jul 28, 2015 i recently reread the giver and watched the movie for the first time. Louis lowry made the ending very vague on purpose, to start up theories and spark interest. It is unclear whether or not robyns baby is gordos or simons, but gordo gives the hint, its all in the eyes, you see. Why do you think jonas is so apprehensive about it. Still, for those who havent read these other 2 books, the ending of the giver allows a reader to draw their own conclusions about what happens to jonas, and that is the genius of it. I wanted her to take off her clothes and get into the tub, he explained quickly.
Nov 22, 2016 the arc of the fountain isnt about a man who found the fountain of youth or the tree of life, ate its bark, and lived to be over 500 years old so that he could rejuvenate the tree in a dying. Ending eventually, jonas finds a sled, like the one that he rode in a memory from the. Below is a list of discussion questions that a teacher could use throughout the teaching of the giver. What is the meaning of the ending of the giver answers. These questions have been created with blooms taxonomy in mind. Parents need to know that the the giver is a dystopian thriller based on author lois lowrys bestselling 1993 novel which has sparked some controversy since its publication and landed on some bannedbook lists. What many dont realise is the ending is meant to be deeply pondered over. The givers ending explained the giver is an adaptation of the lois lowry novel starring jeff bridges and meryl streep. Meanwhile, the giver meets with the chief elder over his training with jonas. In the gift 2015, married couple robyn rebecca hall and simon callem jason bateman are persistently visited by the seemingly menacing gordo joel edgerton, simons former classmate.
He decides to rescue gabriel and escape the community, and they grow steadily weaker as they travel through an unfamiliar wintery landscape. Can someone explain the end of the giver by lois lowry to me. Everyone started to laugh and the children giggled. Leaving the ending of this book ambiguous would encourage. Once he gets to elsewhere, or gets far enough away from his. The movie adaptation of the giver, lois lowrys newbery medalwinning ya novel, was years in the making. This movie was based on the giver, not a literal adaptation of the book. This movie depicts social issues of the first half of the 1960s, including birth control, abortion, and police corruption. The film is based on the 1993 novel the giver by lois lowry.
The ending of the giver is jonas shaking off a neardeath experience and returning to live with his family. The content is best suited to teens and adults, but even mature preteens could likely handle the content with some guidance from adults. As jonas made his way down the hill, he saw a girl in the distance. Based on lois lowrys beloved novel, the giver centers on a young man living in a seemingly ideal world of conformity. The haunting story of the giver centers on jonas brenton thwaites, a young man who lives in a seemingly ideal, if colorless, world of conformity and contentment. Do not delve in if you want the film to be a surprise. Dont use this movie to write about an essay or to awsenser any test questions for the giver. Aug 15, 2014 the giver movie is a surprisingly generic addition to the young adult film genre especially for a story that champions individuality and selfexpression. I believe it is one of his best, its dark character study is. The giver ends with jonass rejection of his communitys ideal of sameness. Litcharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in the giver, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work. Aug 15, 2014 the giver is a cautionary tale about what happens when language is controlled and limitedground well covered for all time in 1984where citizens have no language available to them outside of newsspeak. He showed receiver a house, he gave him a feeling about riding a sled.
It received a peoples choice award nomination for favorite dramatic movie. Since the novel is commonly used in middle school classrooms, the adaptation will appeal to tweens and teens whove read and loved it. As jonas receives these memories, he breaks the cardinal rule against sharing them with others, thereby getting in trouble with the watchful chief elder. The giver is telling jonas that he intends to commit suicide. A books climax and its ending two of the most important and memorable parts of its plot. Now, by writing a sequel focusing on jonas more so than his brief appearance in gathering blue, doesnt that take away the joy of arguing and discussing what really happens at the end of the giver. Jonass next session with the giver has them playing music on the piano and sharing a memory of a party with people dancing and having a great time.
As he begins to discover the dark truths of his communitys past, he realizes he must escape to protect those he loves a challenge nobody has ever succeeded at. The ending to the giver is sort of a take it how you like it deal. At the top of a hill, jonas finds a sled and rides it down toward a community with lit windows and music. In the movie the giver, giverjeff bridges showed jonas a sled as past memory. Movie few books are as cherished as lois lowrys modern classic, and the movies changes may be too much for fans to forgive.
The giver movie ending changed by weinstein business. The people of jonass community dont understand genuine emotion or pain, because their lifestyles allow no opportunity to experience it. Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him. You will write a brief explanation for what you think is going on in the giver. This movie has details changed from the actual story to make it more interesting or whatever.
You may modify or change your theory at any time, up until we finish the book, but you must rewrite your explanation. Then, your job will be to find evidence in the book to back up your theory. One of the most important aspects of the giver is the ambiguity of its ending. Jonas was petrified that he would be chastised for gabriels mishap, but he was wrong. Its starting from when jonas and gabriel started down the hill on the sled. Answering that question is going to require delving into some spoilers for the giver, both the book and the movie. Aug 15, 2014 based on lois lowrys beloved novel, the giver centers on a young man living in a seemingly ideal world of conformity.
It is possible that when lowry wrote the giver, she had a sequel in mind. The man was wrinkled, and his eyes, though piercing in their unusual lightness, seemed tired. Extended ending all at once, everyone on the living room stopped what they were doing and looked at jonas and gabe. While gordos actions and intentions seem highly disturbing, by the end we learn key information that may reverse our sympathies.
In the book, the giver explains that when rosemary, the previous receiver, was released, the memories she received went out to everyone in the community. Random houses official page for the giver this features lois lowrys message to her readers about the novel. Some readers feel that the interpretation of the ending determines the message of the book. The giver is written from the point of view of jonas, an elevenyearold boy living in a futuristic society that has eliminated all pain, fear, war, and hatred.
I had an assignment for communication arts to write an alternate ending for the giver. Aug 16, 2014 10 big differences between the giver book and movie. Apr 14, 2017 why the giver movie will disappoint the books fans book vs. Many people are dissatisfied with the ending of the giver. The ending of the giver is extremely ambiguous and highly controversial. But that doesnt mean that the writing is childish or boringits economical, but full of imagery. And if you havent read the giver yet, you really should go and do that. I believe it is one of his best, its dark character study is definitely not your typical james garner movie. Jonas is walking home in the freezing cold in some underdeveloped part of the world probably northern canada, since he. Can someone explain the end of the giver by lois lowry. The film is based on the 1993 young adult novel of the same name by lois lowry. Jonas ran towards the music as fast as his legs could carry him. Nov 17, 2015 louis lowry made the ending very vague on purpose, to start up theories and spark interest.
There are some tweaks to the ending not found in the book that really dont make a whole lot of sense, but work. After lois lowry published the giver in 1993, she wrote three more books starting with gathering blue in 2000, messenger in 2004, and son in 2012 to form the giver quartet. Get an answer for what is a understandable interpretation of the ending of the giver. Lois lowrys 1993 bestselling novel enters the ya movie marketplace. The author doesnt tell us what the real ending of the story is. Here is my narrative piece of after the ending of the giver behind him, across vast distances of space and time, from the place he had left, he thought he heard music too.
996 276 1379 1238 1492 638 1243 1373 885 1397 652 18 1207 689 143 781 38 530 820 1249 365 751 818 709 898 868 541 77 560 194 674 1463 1280 1285 1379 1138